TradeJournal Pro vs 3Commas
A mature crypto bot platform — DCA and grid strategies, backtesting, portfolio tools. It's not a Telegram signal copier for forex: no MT4/MT5, and no private-channel parsing.
TradeJournal Pro
22/22
listed capabilities
3Commas
6/22
listed capabilities
Platforms
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| MT4 / MT5 execution | ||
| cTrader execution | ||
| Binance & Bybit futures | ||
| Cloud execution (no VPS) |
Signal sources
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Telegram (any private channel)3Commas is strategy-driven, not channel-driven | ||
| Discord | ||
| TradingView webhooks | ||
| WhatsApp + IMAP email |
Signal intel
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| AI text parsing | ||
| AI image / screenshot OCR | ||
| Channel quality scoring |
Risk
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Configurable prop-firm controlsControls reduce risk; they do not guarantee compliance with a firm's rules | ||
| Drawdown guard + daily loss limit |
Journal
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Built-in trading journal & analytics3Commas now lists a trading journal; its workflow is crypto-focused | ||
| AI trade coach | ||
| Hash-linked recorded outcomes |
Testing
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Paper trading mode | ||
| Backtester3Commas backtests bot strategies; we backtest signal channels |
Other
| Feature | TJP | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Signal marketplace | ||
| Free plan (journal + analytics) | ||
| Free starting option without card3Commas says its 7-day trial requires payment details; TJP's never-paid EA starting allowance does not | ||
| 7-day money-back guarantee |
Choose the execution workflow that fits you
New-account EA allowance: never-paid accounts get 1 account, 1 channel and 12 signals/month — no card.
Start free3Commas pricing shown: From $20/mo. Comparison based on publicly available information on 3commas.io, checked August 10, 2026. Features and pricing change often, so check the provider’s site before deciding. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we’ll correct it.